Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 132 excludes certain amounts of employer-provided “qualified transportation fringes” – generally, transit passes, qualified parking, and transportation in a “commuter highway vehicle” between work and home – from an employee’s taxable compensation. However, under the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017, effective for 2018 and after, Section 274(a)(4) denies the employer a deduction for providing employees with these fringes (unless the expenses are treated as taxable compensation to the employees who receive them, in which case they may be deductible as compensation under Section 162; or unless they are incurred as necessary for ensuring the safety of employees under Section 274(l)).
In 2018, the IRS issued Notice 2018-99 (the Notice) to provide a methodology for employers to use to determine the amount of nondeductible expenses for employer-provided employee parking until proposed regulations are issued. See our prior Insight for a detailed discussion of that methodology.
Having just ended the second calendar year in which this provision has been in effect, we wanted to remind affected employers of the non-deductibility of non-taxable employer-provided employee parking expenses, and to provide examples of calculations of nondeductible employee parking expenses under the multistep methodology provided under the Notice.
An employer owns a surface parking lot adjacent to its office and incurs $10,000 of total parking expenses. The parking lot has 500 spaces that are used by its customers and employees. There are usually 50 employees parking in unreserved parking spaces during normal working hours on a typical business day. The employer usually has approximately 300 unreserved spots that are empty during normal business hours on a typical business day.
Step 1: The employer has no parking spaces that are exclusively reserved for its employees.
Step 2: Is the parking lot used primarily for the general public?
- 50 of the employer’s employees park in 500 spaces
- 50 / 500 = 10% employee use.
- Because only 10% of the employer’s parking lot is used for employee parking, the lot is primarily used for the general public (90%). The “greater than 50%” test under the Notice is passed, and there is no need to move on to Step 3.
An employer owns a surface parking lot adjacent to its office and incurs $10,000 of total parking expenses. The parking lot has 500 spaces that are used by the employer’s customers and employees. Fifty of the employer’s officers park in the lot in reserved spaces, and an additional 150 of the employer’s employees park in unreserved spaces during normal working hours on a typical business day. The employer usually has approximately 300 unreserved spaces that are empty during normal business hours on a typical business day.
Step 1: The employer has 50 spaces that are exclusively reserved for its employees.
- 50 / 500 = 10% employee use
- 10% X $10,000 parking expenses = $1,000 of nondeductible parking expense.
Step 2: Is the remainder of the parking lot used primarily for the general public?
- 500 spaces less 50 reserved spaces = 450 remaining spaces
- 150 of the employer’s employees park in the remaining 450 spaces
- 150 / 450 = 33% employee use
- Since only 33% of the employer’s parking lot is used for employee parking, the lot is primarily used for the general public (67%). The “greater than 50%” test is passed, and there is no need to move on to Step 3.
- The total amount of nondeductible parking expense is $1,000, taken from Step 1.
*Example from IRS Notice 18-99.
What Does CohnReznick Think?
We anticipate greater detail when proposed regulations are provided. Until such time, employers should continue to work with the rules provided under the Notice, including, as applicable, the use of its multistep approach. The Notice specifies that the Treasury Department and the IRS have determined that the taxable compensation deduction exception under Section 274(e)(2) does apply to employer-provided employee parking (i.e., an employer that treats an employee’s parking expense as taxable to the employee can deduct the expense); however, the Notice does not provide any amplification regarding the Section 274(l) deduction exception for employer-provided employee commuter benefits “necessary for ensuring the safety of the employee.” We continue to await additional guidance regarding the Section 274(l) exception.
Any advice contained in this communication, including attachments and enclosures, is not intended as a thorough, in-depth analysis of specific issues. Nor is it sufficient to avoid tax-related penalties. This has been prepared for information purposes and general guidance only and does not constitute professional advice. You should not act upon the information contained in this publication without obtaining specific professional advice. No representation or warranty (express or implied) is made as to the accuracy or completeness of the information contained in this publication, and CohnReznick LLP, its members, employees and agents accept no liability, and disclaim all responsibility, for the consequences of you or anyone else acting, or refraining to act, in reliance on the information contained in this publication or for any decision based on it.
InsightAn overview of tax provisions in Biden’s American Families PlanBrian Newman, Stephen Gregory, Yasmina BersbachRead how President Biden’s recently introduced plan would change income and capital gains tax rates, various tax credits, and more.
InsightQualified emergency financial aid grants for student COVID-19 relief are nontaxableLori Rothe Yokobosky, Laura KielczewskiCertain funds awarded to help students with COVID-19-related expenses are excluded from their gross income. Read about impacts to credits, reporting, and more.
InsightThe Restaurant Revitalization Fund: What to knowStephanie O’Rourk, Taylor SphonRead about eligibility, application guidelines, grant amount calculations, and more key information on the American Rescue Plan Act’s RRF program.
InsightNew York State sets new Department of State filing requirements for nonprofitsLori Rothe Yokobosky, Sima Wolfson, Zach SegalLearn about the Annual Financial Report, Funding Disclosure Report, and Financial Disclosure Report – who must file and how, when they are due, and more.
InsightNew York State’s new pass-through entity (PTE) tax: A closer lookArvinder Kaur, Peter Rabinowitz, Corey L. RosenthalRead highlights of New York’s new PTE tax provisions, and what partners and shareholders should know about making the election, the tax rates and credit, and more.
InsightEmployee Retention Credit (ERC) now available for all of 2021, and PPP loan recipients can claim ERCsDana FriedRead how ERC requirements have changed for 2021, including what counts as qualified wages, who is an eligible employer, the maximum credit amount, and more.
InsightFlorida enacts remote seller sales tax economic nexus and marketplace facilitator filing requirementsScott Smith, Suzanne Wilson, Wendy Zee GalexBeginning July 1, 2021, those that hit a certain sales threshold must collect and remit sales tax on taxable sales delivered into the state. Read more.