Restaurant distress is rising: Why early action matters more
Restaurant operators face rising costs, softer traffic, and tighter margins. Learn the warning signs of distress and why early action matters.
For restaurant operators, the past several years have felt like a series of whiplash moments. The pandemic shut dining rooms down. The reopening brought a surge of demand. And now, many operators are facing a very different reality, one where higher costs and softer traffic are colliding at the same time.
Understanding how the industry arrived at this point, recognizing the warning signs of distress, and taking action early can give restaurant operators more flexibility to address challenges before their options narrow.
From shutdown to euphoria
The story starts with COVID-19. When restaurants were forced to close, the immediate challenge was clear: customers disappeared almost overnight. For many operators, navigating that disruption required difficult decisions, from restructuring through the courts to pursuing solutions outside of bankruptcy.
As the industry emerged from the pandemic, the mood shifted quickly. Diners came back eager to eat out and spend, and many restaurants posted sales numbers they had not seen in years. Operators moved to capitalize on that momentum by investing in their properties, capital expenditures, systems, and technology, and by growing their unit counts.
Technology in particular was a turning point. Restaurants had not historically been at the forefront of tech adoption, but almost overnight, they were. All of that came at a cost, and much of it was financed with debt.
The challenge was that no one knew how long the post-pandemic rebound would last. Today, many operators are carrying debt incurred during that period into a markedly different operating environment.
The cost squeeze of 2024 through 2026
Operators are now confronting several pressures at once, including fuel costs, which flow through into higher product costs, and to rising minimum wages. Together, those hit two of the biggest line items on a restaurant’s P&L.
Rent can add another layer of pressure. During the pandemic, many owners and operators restructured their leases and received concessions from landlords. But landlords often looked to recapture those concessions in later years, which means some operators may now be paying more in rent than they were before the pandemic.
Labor adds its own pressure. The restaurant industry already deals with high turnover, and depending on where an operator does business, state-level minimum wage changes can have a significant impact. Operators are challenged to hire, and the people they do hire cost more.
These pressures are compounded by softer demand and declining revenue. When costs rise at the same time the top line comes under pressure, the result can be a perfect storm for restaurant distress.
When raising prices backfires
The natural response to higher costs is a menu price increase. But higher prices can drive traffic down. The result is a top line that may shrink even after pricing goes up, while costs continue to climb. That creates major margin compression and, ultimately, a business that is not generating enough cash flow to cover its obligations and fixed costs.
Discounting carries its own risks. That the industry has seen a number of filings at the franchisee level recently, and meal deals designed to drive foot traffic can crush margins even further than standard pricing would.
Discounting may help drive short-term traffic, but relying on reduced prices for an extended period can further strain already compressed margins.
Franchisees also face costs that company-operated restaurants do not, including royalties and advertising fund contributions paid to the franchisor. For franchisees under pressure, the conversation may include seeking some leeway from the franchisor on those costs, along with addressing underperforming locations.
Understanding the customer
Not every segment of the industry is feeling the pressure equally. Quick service, fast casual, casual, and high-end dining each face different dynamics, and franchising is present across all of them.
High-end restaurants, such as a steakhouse in New York City, may remain busy because some consumers continue to dine out despite the challenges. The pullback is coming from consumers who have to watch every dollar, and they make up a large share of many restaurants’ customer base. Even a $12 meal is money that could go toward groceries, where prices are also elevated. Add in the cost of gas to drive to a restaurant, and the decision to dine out becomes even harder.
With discretionary income pinched, consumers are either trading down from higher-end restaurants to lower-priced options or skipping dining out altogether in favor of the grocery store. That shows up directly in traffic.
The takeaway: operators need a clear understanding of who their customers are, and the data to back it up. That insight can guide decisions today and going forward about how to give consumers a reason to choose their restaurant.
Where restructuring comes in
For multi-unit operators, a four-wall assessment is often a starting point. Which locations are profitable, and which are cash flow negative? From there, the question becomes how to exit the leases on underperforming units. For some restaurant companies, bankruptcy becomes an option because the U.S. Bankruptcy Code provides mechanisms that allow companies to reject leases.
But closing locations is not a simple fix when debt is involved. If a company has significant debt and is counting on, for example, 200 operating locations, closing 25% of them will affect its ability to cover debt service. Many restaurants are struggling to cover operating costs, let alone the debt service sitting on their balance sheets.
Warning signs operators shouldn’t ignore
One of the most difficult aspects of financial distress is recognizing early enough that the business is moving in the wrong direction. Waiting for conditions to improve, or attempting to address mounting problems without an objective assessment, can allow those challenges to deepen. Several warning signs warrant serious attention:
Declining same-store sales. A significant decrease is a clear signal that something needs to change.
Shrinking operating margins. Rising costs paired with softer traffic erode profitability quickly.
Tightening cash flow. Drawing on a line of credit to keep operations running is a red flag.
Missed rent payments. When the business cannot generate the cash flow to pay rent, the problem has become urgent.
Time is an ally
In a distress situation, time can be one of an operator’s most valuable assets. The more runway a company has after identifying a problem, the more leeway it has to find solutions. When a company calls saying it cannot make payroll on Friday, the options narrow dramatically, and it can become a free fall into Chapter 11 or another outcome.
Identifying what is and is not working and confronting difficult decisions early can help preserve options. If a company does need to use the court system, the process is much smoother when it has negotiated with stakeholders ahead of time. Going into a filing, the company may have greater clarity around which leases it will reject and what the revitalized business will look like on the other side.
Simply put, earlier action can create greater optionality.
The value of an outside perspective
An outside advisor brings objectivity. Some management teams fall into the pattern of believing things will get better next month, and the hole keeps getting deeper. A frank, independent conversation can help break that cycle.
Breadth of experience matters too. Because CohnReznick works with many clients in the restaurant space, our team sees common themes across the industry and can suggest ideas management may not have considered, drawing on what has worked elsewhere. Strong relationships throughout the industry extend that perspective even further.
Take the next step early
For operators feeling the pressure, early intervention can make a meaningful difference. Bringing in an advisor before the situation becomes critical creates space to peel back the layers, identify the core causes of the challenges, and evaluate the full range of options before it is too late.
The earlier operators recognize the warning signs and begin evaluating their options, the more flexibility they may have to determine the path forward.
Related services
Our solutions are tailored to each client’s strategic business drivers, technologies, corporate structure, and culture.