Homebuilding should be booming right now. Why isn't it?
The economy has posted a record 121 months of expansion. Job growth is steady, and wage growth finally seems to be accelerating. Those economics are usually a recipe for strong new home sales. But right now, the homebuilding industry is stuck in a low growth mode.
Typically, when Americans feel more secure in their finances and the economy, they clamor for single-family homes. According to CohnReznick Director Steven Friedman, demand is not where it has been in the past. And settlements are down substantially.
Existing home sale inventory is low, but new home sales haven’t accelerated as economists and many builders had anticipated. And while home prices have recovered since the end of the great recession, they have flatlined over the past six months – the much-anticipated Spring selling season really didn’t materialize in a meaningful way.
“New and resale demand should be exceedingly strong, but it’s not,” Friedman said. “Economists are seeing these strange data points and saying, ‘This doesn’t add up.’”
In a normal market, Friedman said, the number of families settling down in a new home should be between 900,000 and 1.2 million annually. Instead, that number is sitting below 700,000. What’s causing this slowdown is a matter of debate in economic circles, but Friedman pins much of the responsibility on demographics.
Friedman explained that the current American population clusters around two large age groups: 55 to 75 year olds – baby boomers, and 19 to 37 year olds – millennials, which is creating what he calls a barbell effect.
Many boomers are looking for affluent millennials to buy the large houses where they raised families, but millennials often aren’t ready to purchase them. Many are still saddled with student debt or have not been able to build up savings because of the last recession. And their paychecks haven’t kept pace with increasing home prices.
The main impetus to buy a house for the first time is typically the birth of a first or second child, Friedman said. Because they are staying childless longer, millennials are deferring demand for single-family homes. In fact, the average age of a home buyer today is 47 – and that is well above historic norms.
Boomers are facing the tough decision of whether to relocate, either to another state or locally, or simply to age in place. Many are choosing to stay put, either to stay close to family or because they lack the capital to move during retirement, further reducing the demand for new housing.
However, Friedman rejected the idea that millennials are uninterested in home ownership and would prefer to rent downtown apartments in perpetuity.
“Despite protestations to the contrary, millennials long-term do not want to be urban cave dwellers,” Friedman said. “They will relocate to the suburbs, just like their parents, to raise their children in a safe environment with good schools. What is changing is the identity and location of those suburbs.”
The lack of strong imminent housing demand puts pressure on homebuilders to find lots in markets that will pay off sooner rather than down the road. Friedman suggested that homebuilders focus on markets where job growth is strong and local companies provide good benefits, because where millennials want to live is usually dictated by where they want to work.
Homebuilders are also becoming much more cost-conscious, thanks to economic pressures. The stock of available, affordable land capable of necessary entitlements is shrinking, while the costs of labor and building materials are headed through the roof. That’s resulting the shrinking square footage of the average new home
Funding for residential development and construction is also harder to come by. While some large banks like Wells Fargo and U.S. Bank have active homebuilding lending businesses, Friedman said, many others have abandoned the business. And while regional and local banks are often active in the homebuilding markets, their lending capacity typically is limited.
All of this adds up to an environment in which homebuilders need to exercise what Friedman called community discipline.
“Builders do best when they have a thoughtful number of active communities,” Friedman said. “Too many stretches a builder too thin and hurts profitability; too few means overhead overburdens each home sale. So, the happy medium is thoughtful product, attractively priced in a good submarket, built with a strong eye toward cost efficiencies.”
The current market may also favor smaller, privately held homebuilders that can build for particular demographic niches. Public homebuilders often need to hit a specific goal of homes built and sold to cover their overhead in each quarter. As a result, they sometimes build for an “average” buyer or a typical buyer in a given cohort. Thoughtful private builders are able to pursue more-segmented groups, which Friedman said can be lucrative.
As more millennials move to the suburbs, though, homebuilders may have to face a future in which for-sale housing demand is lower. When demand is low, keeping costs low is crucial.
“With fewer starts and settlements, there is pressure on builders to become more efficient,” Friedman said. “They need to manage overhead costs better because they have fewer unit sales to recover those costs.”
This feature was produced by Bisnow Branded Content in collaboration with CohnReznick. Bisnow news staff was not involved in the production of this content.
InsightAffordable Housing News & Views - February 2021Beth MullenFrom legislative issues to technical updates to performance and industry trends, CohnReznick's Affordable Housing News & Views has the housing tax credit industry covered.
InsightCapitol Connection: The 4% fix, the AHCIA, and the 117th CongressGet insights from Beth Mullen and Bob Moss on the Affordable Housing Credit Improvement Act, the fixed 4% Low-Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC) rate, and more.
InsightLIHTC Q&A: The more things change… the more questions we haveRead LIHTC insights and updates, on COVID-19 relief changes to qualified basis calculations; alternative depreciation; the average income set-aside; and more.
InsightHow Opportunity Zones can succeedIra Weinstein, managing principal and Opportunity Zones practice leader at CohnReznick, and Steve Glickman, founder and CEO of Develop LLC, an Opportunity Zones advisory firm, and former co-founder and CEO of the Economic Innovation Group, joined OpportunityDb.com's Opportunity Zones podcast hosted by Jimmy Atkinson.